Greg Egan complains about sloppy reviews of his latest novel:
About half the reviews of Incandescence made at least one of the following false assertions:
- The Splinter orbits a neutron star.
- Rakesh visits the Splinter.
- The relationship between the novel’s two threads is never revealed.
- The reader learns nothing about the Aloof.
The first two errors result from failing to notice that Egan violates a common pattern of First Contact stories: chapters alternate between two sets of characters who would conventionally meet in the end. Odd-numbered chapters of Incandescence are about Rakesh, a human who learns of evidence of DNA life in an unexpected place and follows the trail; even-numbered chapters are about the discovery of general relativity by the inhabitants of the Splinter, an artificial worldlet orbiting a black hole. Rakesh never finds the Splinter; he arrives at another artificial worldlet, with the same origin as the Splinter but orbiting a neutron star. So there is a clear link between the two threads, but it’s at the wrong end.
And unless I missed something the Aloof remain as mysterious as ever, though slightly less aloof than they seemed before.
Two stories in the same universe as Incandescence are online: Riding the Crocodile and Glory (pdf).